Creative Scotland - getting ready to miss the great big digital opportunity.

Photocredit - Chris Watt

Creative Scotlad was formed on 1st July 2010, so that will be exactly six months ago today. For that day I wrote a piece in the Scotsman which the Creative Scotland chief executive, Andrew Dixon, directly quoted from at the launch event in the Roxy later that same month. I proposed diverting money out of subsidising individual arts companies and performances and putting it into building a digital infrastucture which delivered listings, ticketing and EVERYTHING else that web 2.0 functionality makes possible. By taking a pro-active, strategic approach to enabling people both in Scotland and anywhere else to participate in the arts in Scotland, the economic benefit would outweigh the cost - and much more importantly, the access an the audiences for the arts in Scotland would be increased.

I've also banged on about this idea here and here and here and here and here to explore the details and opportunities. I've met with Andrew Dixon, the List, the Edinburgh Pilot Portal Project and Scottish Enterprise; given presentations at two Barcamps and sought to battle through the fears of the naysayers in order to enable them to share the vision of a digital strategy for Scotland which is commensurate with the opportunity the techology offers and appropriate to who we are and will be as a nation (not just white men in kilts)


At this point, on new year's day, I have to concede failure. Whatever discussion Creative Scotland may or may not have about this idea it now seems clear that when their strategy is finally unveiled in March it will be more of the same old subsidies - pretending to be investment. Audiences will still be treated as statistical data rather than people and the prospect of Listings, Ticketing and EVERYTHING else Web 2.0. functionality makes possible will be just another opportunity missed. But I don't care, I'm not taking this personally (oh yes he is). I'm not fussed that Fiona Hyslop and her team are supporting the idea of a New Scottish TV company, which is going to cost £75 million, so we can all stay home and watch even more TV - as if that's going to answer any of the countries cultural/health needs. I'm not fussed that Fiona Hyslop and her team seem unable to grasp the opportunity to use digital techology to get out of our homes and into the public places where we can communally engage in the live experience of......well it's your choice.


Happy New Year.






Views: 34

Tags: arts, creative scotland

Add a Comment

You need to be a member of 38minutes to add comments!

Join 38minutes

Comment by Richard Saville-Smith on January 8, 2011 at 21:55

Cheers Kevin. It is my humble view that people like me should not be deemed difficult, but rather welcomed by those who know better (sic) and if They want to dismiss positions such as mine, they should do it on the basis of  logic and (researched) facts rather than prejudice and the fear of cohent criticism.

Comment by Kevin Bradshaw on January 7, 2011 at 14:23

Great piece Richard. Big kudos to you for being smart and brave enough to be honest. You'll be labelled as "difficult" now :-)


Good for you, we need a lot more smart, honest, difficult people if we are ever to get Scotland to produce world-class digital media companies.


Latest Network Activity

Fablevision Studios posted a status
""Growing Communities Glasgow" shows just how effective social enterprise and community projects can be."
22 hours ago
Fablevision Studios posted a video

Growing Communities Glasgow

People creating places for little green spaces. Community gardens sprouting up around the 'dear green place' - Glasgow (/ˈɡlaːzɡoʊ/ gla(h)z-goh;[4] Scots: Gl...
22 hours ago
Lucy Harwood replied to Lucy Harwood's discussion 'Commission available: Design and programming of bespoke display units for hospital exhibition.' in the group Wanted; Jobs, Skills, Resource
"This opportunity has been extended until 19th October. It was also been adapted to focus on curation. Please see for latest details."
ray allan is now a member of 38minutes
Paul Bruce posted a blog post

Edinburgh Short Film Festival Online Box Office Now Open

The Edinburgh Short Film Festival starts on November 11th, screening 71 short films from 23 countries, with pavement cinema, q and as and film-makers flying in from across the world!Our online box office is now open for tickets for all our events!Make sure you don't miss out by getting your tickets here:ESFF Box Office…See More
Paul Bruce posted an event

EDINBURGH SHORT FILM FESTIVAL 2015 at Summerhall, Edinburgh

November 11, 2015 at 8pm to November 22, 2015 at 1am
We're super-stoked about this year's programme and guests featured in our latest blog article.. a preview of the 2015 programme!ESFF 2015 PreviewSee More
Oct 1
Deirdre Robertson is now a member of 38minutes
Sep 25
Jacob Wright posted a blog post

Pioneer Puts Emphasis on Evolution with CDJ Packages & DJ Effect Units

CDJ (Compact Disk Jockey) is a line of CD players from Pioneer DJ, allowing analogue control from CDs by using an imitated vinyl control surface. In today’s age, Pioneer has landed with a bang on the digital DJ world with excellent all in one solution that is designed in sync to be perfect for DJ’s of all abilities.Day by day with revolutionary DJ equipment, Pioneer not only entrenches the existing users but also attracts new users; even those who have only worked with software solutions in the…See More
Sep 24

Companies, Groups and Organizations.


38minutes is run by a small group of
volunteers, including:


Nicola Sinclair

Site editor




Gavin Robertson

Groups Co-ordinator




Espen Brunborg

Runs the Web group




Ashley Smith Hammond

Runs Digital Innovation group




Frank McGowan

Runs TV & Film group




Brian Baglow

Runs Gaming group




Would you like to volunteer? Get in touch!


  • Add Photos
  • View All


  • Add Videos
  • View All

© 2015   Created by Nicola Sinclair.

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service